10 Reasons Colleges Fail At Business Model Innovation

Wednesday, October 12, 2016


View Larger +

Saul Kaplan, BIF

Higher education has a business model problem. The business model for U.S. colleges and universities — how they create, deliver, and capture value — hasn’t changed since Harvard, our country’s first college, was founded in 1636. Our higher education system is a national treasure that creates enormous societal value, but its 380-year-old business model fails to deliver affordable access and post-secondary credentials to an increasing percentage of our population.

The American social contract was clear throughout the Industrial Era. While many jobs moved out of reach for those without a college degree, there were still ample opportunities for everyone to earn a good living in order to support a family. The U.S. became an economic powerhouse with a robust and thriving middle class.

Then the rug got pulled out from under the economy. The Industrial Era ended, taking with it most of the career opportunities for those without a college degree or relevant post-secondary credential.

The existing social contract broke and was replaced by a new one, with the expectation that everyone gain some form of post- secondary credential in order to be relevant to the new economy and to earn enough to sustain a good living.

Unfortunately, while societal expectations for higher education changed, its business model hasn’t. As a result, far too many citizens have been left without affordable access to a post-secondary credential that will put them on a pathway to a good living.

When I was an accidental bureaucrat leading a state economic development agency, my friends asked me how, after working in the private sector for so long, I could put up with government’s slow pace. I responded that, after 20 years in the private sector, I was convinced that big corporations didn’t move quickly either.

I also teased my friends in academia that colleges and universities move even more slowly than either big business or government! Higher education has the most intransigent business model on the planet.

Here are 10 reasons why colleges fail at business model innovation:

1. College presidents and boards don’t really want a new business model.

Business model exploration doesn’t happen if senior leadership doesn’t want it to. It takes strong leadership at the top to pedal the bicycle of today’s business model while simultaneously creating the conditions to explore and test new ones. The good news is that a growing number of higher education leaders are starting to get it.

2. Our hands are tied. Accreditation is at stake.

Accreditation is the most common excuse to protect the higher education status quo. But existing accreditation rules and guidelines leave far more room for business model exploration than most leaders will admit or explore. Accreditation has been more about protecting industry incumbents from new business model competition than protecting the interests of students or society. This must change.

3. Classroom learning is king and nothing else matters.

You would think colleges would have figured out by now that most learning happens outside the classroom, but sadly, too many haven’t. You would also think that the ability to access the best information, thinking, and practices from anywhere, any time via the Internet would change the role played by faculty in and out of the classroom. But sadly, it hasn’t.

4. Campus is the center of the universe.

Students want experiential learning opportunities and direct connections to the real-world laboratories of local communities with which to apply their ideas and solutions generatively. Campus bubbles are too confining. The value proposition for residence-based colleges, along with escalating costs, will be challenged by students like never before.

5. Cannibalization is off the table.

I love it when college leaders say, innovate all you want as long as it doesn’t affect current operations. Innovation agendas that only include projects that can be done without impacting the way things work today leave colleges vulnerable to being disrupted by innovators without similar constraints.

6. Not enough connecting with unusual suspects.

Colleges and universities are wonderful places full of diverse people, departments, and disciplines. And yet there is surprisingly little interaction across silos. The same is true off-campus. Too much time is spent interacting with the usual suspects, rather than exploring the opportunities and people at the edges.

7. Do innovators get tenure?

Are young faculty members who try to change how their colleges work and how students learn rewarded with tenure? Seems ironic that tenured faculty who have already been awarded ‘academic freedom’ are often the least innovative when it comes to exploring new learning approaches and models.

8. Great idea, what’s the ROI?

Using traditional financial metrics to compare innovation projects works great for incremental improvements to today’s business model, but is useless for early exploration of possible new business models. We won’t know what is repeatable and scalable until we try new approaches. But we will never try new approaches, if we hold them accountable for a predictable financial return while they are still in the exploration phase.

9. They shoot business model innovators, don’t they?

Ever notice what happens to people who want to transform their college’s business model? They are humored for a while, until far too many of them get frustrated and leave for conditions more conducive to innovation. We have to celebrate and support business model innovators everywhere, including in colleges.

10. You want to experiment in the real world — are you crazy?

You can’t analyze your way to business model innovation. You have to explore your way there. And you don’t explore in a conference room or with a presentation deck — you explore in the real world. New business model concepts must be imagined, prototyped, and tested in the real world.

Subsidizing the costs of today’s higher education business model can take the sting out of college sticker-shock and debt service loads for some, but isn’t scalable to the size of the problem. Tweaks to current business models aren’t enough.

If our society is going to fulfill the promise of affordable access to the post-secondary credentials necessary to thrive in a 21st century economy, we must enable more higher education leaders to explore and test new business models. Nothing short of a proliferation of new higher education business models will allow us to deliver affordable access to post-secondary credentials under the new social contract.

Too many students and citizens are waiting for us to fix higher education’s business model problem. Let’s get going.

Saul Kaplan is the Founder and Chief Catalyst of the Business Innovation Factory (BIF). Saul shares innovation musings on his blog at It’s Saul Connected and on Twitter at @skap5.


Related Slideshow: Power List - Business

View Larger +
Prev Next

Big Bankers

Kevin Tracy and Oliver Bennett— There are deals and there are BIG DEALS. In Rhode Island, with all of the changing players and banking relationships, one reality is pretty much the same. If you have a big deal that needs sophisticated financing, the community banks may not be able to handle it.

Bank of America may have abandoned the Superman Building, but they are still in Rhode Island and still doing big deals. Kevin Tracy, the former Brown golfer and Oliver Bennett — long ago Fleet Bank trainees — are now the guys you bring in for a $50 million deal.  The more things change - the more they stay the same.

View Larger +
Prev Next


John Hazen White, Jr. — White has taken Taco to new levels as he has made a series of strategic acquisitions to bolster the Rhode Island manufacturing company into a global firm.

He continues to be a leader in American manufacturing investing in worker retention and employee training.

Behind the scenes, White is a combination of an adviser and moral compass to many in Rhode Island. Despite taking a lower profile than his Lookout RI days, White is still a force pushing for ethics reform. 

View Larger +
Prev Next


Joe Paolino — Once the young Mayor who took over in the 1980s when Buddy Cianci was forced to resign (the first time), now the leading corporate voice in Providence if not Rhode Island.

While others complain at lunches at the Hope Club and University Club about the plight of the Capital City, Paolino has rolled up his sleeves and taken on issues like panhandling and homelessness.

With a real estate empire that includes much of downtown, some of the top properties in Newport and Hasbro’s campus in Pawtucket to name a few, Paolino has close ties to Governor Gina Raimondo and even closer ties to the Clintons - could a federal appointment be in the works in 2017?

View Larger +
Prev Next


Steve Kirby — No one dominates commercial real estate in Rhode Island like Kirby does on Aquidneck Island. His red “Kirby Commercial” signs are literally everywhere across the island and in Newport proper -- they are more frequent than street signs.

Want to open a clothing store in Newport? Go see Steve Kirby. Looking to launch a startup tech firm? Call Kirby. Developed cool technology and want to start producing for the Navy? Email Kirby.

Kirby maybe the most influential in business on Aquidniick Island. (PS He will tell you which bankers to talk to).

View Larger +
Prev Next

Labor Boss

George Nee — President of the AFL-CIO, Nee is one of the most influential players in business in Rhode Island. 

He is Vice Chair of the Convention Center Authority Board, on the Commerce Corp board, the most influential voice for labor at the State House, and involved one way or another in just about every negotiation on constructing public buildings or issuing a tax stabilization agreement in Providence.

For the most part his public persona has been more muted recently, but that has not impacted his private influence. If it happens in Rhode Island, Nee has probably touched it.

View Larger +
Prev Next


Sally Lapides — If Teddy Roosevelt were alive today and saw the number of Residential Properties’ real estate signs on the East Side he would call it a monopoly and want to break up the company. Lapides not only dominates one of the most affluent sections of Rhode Island, but she also delves into the arts, education and politics.

When you sell the wealthiest and most influential their homes, you make a lot of friends.

Lapides is a force in residential real estate and it will be interesting to see what she does next.

View Larger +
Prev Next


Helena Foulkes — Two of the biggest decisions CVS ever made were the brain children of Foulkes. The Extracare card and the removal of tobacco from its stores were both influenced by Foulkes.

She has emerged as a national power in business and makes all the business lists for top women, but make no mistake - she is wildly influential in Rhode Island. 

She is close to Raimondo and she may decide to jump into political waters in the future - or may decide if she can snag the CEO spot at CVS.

View Larger +
Prev Next

Visionary or Free Rider

Buff Chace — One of downtown Providence's biggest real estate magnates is a lightning rod in the Capital City. Widely considered to be one of the prime catalysts of Downcity's resurgence, Chace's accumulation of properties on Westminster Street is straight out of a Monopoly playbook. 

His recent acquisition of the ProJo building has further solidified his dominance, which has not been without intense scrutiny, given his ability to continually secure -- and extend -- tax stabilization agreements at a time when the city's dire financial straits are close to reaching a head. 

Wealthy, influential, and active in the community, Chace has chaired  the Downtown Providence Parks Conservancy and has been a member of the Executive Committee of the Providence Foundation, and is a director emeritus for GrowSmart RI and a trustee emeritus of Trinity Repertory Theatre.

View Larger +
Prev Next

Big Time

Richard Baccari — One of the biggest real estate developers in New England. For decades he has been a major player in Providence, Rhode Island and the northeast.

During that span, he has been the driving and innovative force behind some of the region's most significant residential and commercial development endeavors. 

See a Stop and Shop development and Baccari probably built it. Has fought back business challenges and much more.


Enjoy this post? Share it with others.


Sign Up for the Daily Eblast

I want to follow on Twitter

I want to Like on Facebook


Stay Connected — Free
Daily Email